- By Rita Rubin
One Florida octogenarian has been getting Pap tests pretty much ever since doctors started using the cervical cancer screening tool in the 1940s, and, her daughter says, she never plans to stop. Yet the American Cancer Society and the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force advise against this screening for women older than 65 who are “low-risk” (those who’ve had a series of normal Pap tests and are in a stable relationship).
Old habits are hard to break. And women and men who’ve been screened for cancers and other conditions for decades sometimes resist stopping, even though they’ve reached the age where the harms — including anxiety over a falsely positive test — might outweigh the benefits.
A Huge Health Problem
“It’s a huge problem and it’s a waste of resources since screening beyond the recommended age increases healthcare costs,” says Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical and scientific officer and executive vice president of the American Cancer Society. “It’s a little bit irrational."
He is not swayed by a recent study in the Cancer Society’s journal Cancer concluding that cervical cancer is more common in women in their late 60s than previously thought: University of Maryland researchers say cervical cancer actually peaks at age 65 to 69 and that screening guidelines may need to be reconsidered.
Brawley maintains that women who are diagnosed with cervical cancer in their 60s have had a series of abnormal Pap tests or haven’t been screened for a decade or more, either of which would disqualify them from stopping screening at 65 under current guidelines.
(MORE: The Essential Health Tests You May Not Realize You Need)
The Factors You Should Consider
But before stopping screening, there are other factors to consider. First and foremost, your own health.
Dr. Albert Siu, who serves as co-vice chair of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, a panel that makes recommendations about preventive care for primary care doctors, says of screenings: “In many cases, we recognize that this is a personal decision between the patient and the doctor."
“The issue really differs by cancer,” says Siu, chairman of geriatrics and palliative medicine at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. He agrees with Brawley that screening low-risk women past age 65 for cervical cancer “is of no benefit. There’s nothing to be gained.”
But with some cancer, Siu says there's uncertainty about how effective screening might be for people in their 80s and beyond, because they haven't been studied. Another factor that should be considered is what other medical conditions the patient has, he says.
The Current Screening Guidelines
Here’s what guidelines say about when to stop screening for three cancers:
Prostate cancer: In many men, prostate cancer is so slow-growing that they might never develop symptoms and end up dying of something else. That’s one reason the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends against screening men of any age with the prostate specific antigen (PSA) test.
The American Urological Association recommends that men 55 to 69 discuss the risks and benefits of PSA screening tests with their doctors before deciding whether to be screened. The urologists’ group doesn’t recommend routine PSA screening in men 70 and older.
According to the American Cancer Society’s guidelines, men at average risk for prostate cancer should begin learning about the risks and benefits of screening at age 50 and continue to be given the option of screening as long as their life expectancy is at least 10 more years.
Breast cancer: Both the American Cancer Society and the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force are revisiting their recommendations about screening mammograms. For now, the Cancer Society says women should continue to get mammograms regardless of their age as long as they don’t have serious chronic health problems such as dementia or short life expectancies.
“Our guidelines are a little weak in this area,” Brawley acknowledges, noting that updated guidelines, expected late this year or early next year, will include more specific language about when to stop screening mammograms.
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force currently recommends that women get screening mammograms every two years from ages 50 through 74 and notes that there is insufficient scientific evidence to assess the harms and benefits of screening women 75 and older. The task force just started updating its guidelines, Siu says, a process that typically takes two or three years.
Colorectal cancer: If a colonoscopy at age 55 or 60 shows that your colon is normal, you’re unlikely ever to develop colorectal cancer, Brawley says. “There (continuation of screening), we are incredibly weak about our recommendations,” he says. “We could be stronger.” For now, the American Cancer Society recommends a screening colonoscopy every 10 years, with no upper age limit, for people at average risk.
“We want to leave it a little open and individualized,” Brawley says, noting that removing polyps destined to become cancer in healthy people in their 80s could save them from being diagnosed with colorectal cancer in their 90s. Screening with a stool blood test is effective and costs 1/100th the price of a colonoscopy, he adds.
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, which is in the process of updating its guidelines, currently recommends against routine colorectal cancer screening in people 76 through 85, although screening some individuals in that age group might be justified. People older than 85 should not be screened, according to the task force.
The bottom line: Consult your doctor as you decide which screenings are right for you.
Rita Rubin is a former USA Today medical writer who now writes about health and science for publications including Next Avenue, WebMD and NBCNews.com.