Borrowing money can enable opportunities otherwise out of reach financially, such as pursuing an education that can lead to employment, buying a car and facilitating a home purchase. However, if not managed effectively, it can undermine your financial well-being. As a retirement researcher, I am worried that debt may be eroding the long-term financial security of many workers who are nearing retirement.
According to a 2017 study by Experian, boomers have an average of $188,828 in mortgage debt and $27,513 in non-mortgage debt. Generation Xers, now entering their fifties, have even higher balances — including $231,774 in mortgage debt and $30,334 in non-mortgage debt.
I lead the nonprofit Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies®, and in our 2017 survey (which included 2,521 workers age 50 or older), debt emerged as a concerning theme.
Experts generally agree that younger people should be more likely to carry debt because they are just getting started and have their careers ahead of them with time to pay it down. Older workers who are closer to retirement, on the other hand, should be more likely to be without debt. In reality, however, our survey found that only 18 percent of age 50+ workers said their household does not have any debt. The three most often cited types of debt they do have: credit cards (56 percent), mortgages (49 percent) and car loans (38 percent).
How Debt Can Eat Away at Retirement Savings
People who are paying off debt have less discretionary income available to save for the future, of course. And saving for retirement has become increasingly essential. In today’s world, we are expected to self-fund an increasing portion of our retirement by saving in 401(k)s, Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) and the like. Meantime, Social Security is in need of reform and traditional pension plans are vanishing.
Unfortunately, some workers are borrowing from their 401(k)s, inhibiting the long-term growth of their accounts.
One in six workers who are 50+ have taken a loan from a 401(k) or similar plan or IRA. Reasons often relate to either paying off some other form of debt (23 percent), an unplanned major expense (24 percent), a financial emergency (16 percent) or medical bills (16 percent) — in other words, financial shocks that may have otherwise led to running up credit cards or other debt.
The median amount in emergency savings for age 50+ workers, our survey found, is only $10,000, which suggests financial fragility and explains why some are turning to retirement plan loans.
Borrowing From a 401(k)
Borrowing from yourself by taking a 401(k) loan may be a good option, but it can be risky. If you can’t repay the loan within the prescribed time for any reason — including a job loss — you may owe the Internal Revenue Service taxes and, if you’re under 59½, a 10 percent early withdrawal tax penalty.
Before the 2017 tax law, you had to repay the loan within 60 days after leaving a job or you’d be hit with the taxes and possibly the penalty. For loans taken after Jan. 1, 2018, when you leave a job, you can now put the money back into the plan, an IRA or a new 401(k) up until the October of the following year and avoid the taxes.
Let me show you the impact of having a 401(k) loan: Age 50+ workers who have never taken a 401(k) loan or early withdrawal have saved a median $188,000 in their retirement accounts. The median retirement savings among those who have taken a 401(k) loan, however, is just $123,000. Even more striking, among the 28 percent who have taken a 401(k) loan and/or an early withdrawal from the plan, their median retirement savings figure is a mere $83,000.
6 Ways to Manage Debt
Here are six ways to effectively manage debt:
- Take an inventory and keep track of your debt including accounts, amounts owed, interest rates and payment terms. Maintain a snapshot to prioritize which accounts to pay off first (i.e., those with higher interest rates).
- Formulate a financial plan that optimizes how you can pay off debt while also saving for the future. When doing so, create a personal balance sheet that includes all of your assets, debts and equity. A financial plan should also consider insurance protections that could help mitigate the expense of financial shocks.
- Build and maintain an excellent credit rating by consistently paying bills on time. Dings on your credit rating may make it more difficult and expensive to obtain loans and credit cards in the future.
- If you’re in a financial bind and stretched beyond your limits, ask your lenders whether they have alternative payment plans. Check with your bank or credit union about debt consolidation opportunities. If you’re thinking about a 401(k) loan, consider the risks and consequences if you are unable to pay yourself back. Once you have done your homework, carefully evaluate your options, set priorities and create an action plan.
- Aspire to retire debt-free, with the possible exception of a mortgage. Exercise extreme caution if you’re contemplating retiring before paying off all your high-interest-rate debt. If you are planning to retire with a mortgage, be sure to do so with a high level of confidence in your ability to make your monthly payments, withstand any shocks in home values and, if need be, pay it off.
- Seek the expertise of a financial adviser, if needed. A professional can offer personalized advice and recommendations.
Careful planning can lead to better outcomes. Although it’s hard work, it’s much easier to successfully address debt-related issues while you’re still in the workforce than to wait until retirement and face the risk of insolvency.
Next Avenue Editors Also Recommend:
- When It’s OK to Retire With Debt
- Mortgage or Consumer Debt; Which Is Better in Retirement?
- Using Your Home Equity for Aging in Place
Next Avenue brings you stories that are inspiring and change lives. We know that because we hear it from our readers every single day. One reader says,
"Every time I read a post, I feel like I'm able to take a single, clear lesson away from it, which is why I think it's so great."
Your generous donation will help us continue to bring you the information you care about. Every dollar donated allows us to remain a free and accessible public service. What story will you help make possible?