Next Avenue Logo

Your Retirement Number: Who Cares?

Calling the obsession 'absurd,' this financial expert has a different strategy

By Walter Updegrave

(This article previously appeared on
I’m all for having goals. If you go to the trouble of setting a target, you’re probably more likely to do something to achieve it.

And, in fact, research from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) 2013 Retirement Confidence Survey shows this is the case. People who say they calculated a savings goal were more than twice as likely to feel very confident they’ll be able to accumulate the money they need to retire.

Still, this obsession with “The Number” — as if you can pin down to a specific dollar figure the amount of money you’ll need 30 years from now to retire comfortably —  is absurd.

(MORE: How to Declare Your Financial Independence)

The Problems With 'The Number'

For one thing, it’s not that precise. Sure, you can go to any number of calculators that will spit out a very specific figure. I mean really specific. Like $1,358,564.

But as exact as the number you get may seem, it’s really no more than a guesstimate — and a squishy one at best.

The amount you actually require could be much lower or much higher depending on a multitude of factors, including whether you enter retirement with a mortgage or other debt, how grand a lifestyle you lead, how your health holds out and how long you live.

Besides, there’s a more fundamental issue of whether it even makes sense to plan on the basis of hitting a large lump sum. A big six- or seven-figure bogey can be daunting.

(MORE: 6 Risks to Your Retirement Security)

Some people may see it and say, “Forget it. I’ll never reach that. Why try?” And even if you’re okay with a big target, research shows that people have a hard time translating big lump sums into spendable income. A large figure can give them a false sense of security as they tend to overestimate the amount they can withdraw from it.

A Better Way to Plan for Retirement

A better strategy: focus on how much income you’ll need in retirement — and whether you’re on track to generate it.

Yes, I know that income and assets are related and one can be derived from the other. I realize, too, that an income goal is also an estimate. But it’s one you can more easily wrap your mind around and equate with a standard of living.

Knowing that the combination of your savings, any pension and Social Security is likely to generate, say, $30,000 a year in today’s dollar’s for retirement while you’re living on $50,000 a year now gives you a much better idea of where you stand than finding you’re currently on track to build a nest egg in 30 years worth, say, $1,358,564.


One more thing. In addition to focusing on income, think also about probabilities. Fact is, there are so many unknowns along the road to retirement — market ups and downs, whether you’ll be able to maintain a savings regimen, the age you’ll retire — that it’s foolish to think that hitting any figure, income or lump sum, is anywhere close to certain.

(MORE: Best Money Advice I Ever Heard)

Estimate Your Chances

It’s more realistic to think in terms of your chances of achieving a secure retirement.

So, for example, if you invest in a mix of 60 percent stocks and 40 percent bonds; save 15 percent of salary a year and retire at 66, you may have a 75 percent chance or probability of being able to generate, say, $40,000 a year in income until age 92.

Many 401(k) plans and the better retirement calculators — like the ones I recommend in my Real Deal Retirement Toolbox —  already use computerized “Monte Carlo” simulations to couch their results this way.

I like this approach not only because it makes it clear we’re dealing with estimates and probabilities, rather than certainties, in these sorts of projections. But it allows you to see how changing your plan a bit —saving more, retiring later, investing differently, etc. — improves or lowers your chances.

So don’t get caught up in this national obsession about “The Number.”

Home in on the income you’ll need and you’ll have a much better idea of where you stand vis a vis a secure retirement — and what you need to do to get there.
Walter Updegrave has written four books on retirement planning and investing. Before launching, he worked at Money magazine for nearly three decades, where he wrote the “Ask the Expert” column for Follow him on Twitter @RealDealRetire

Walter Updegrave is the editor of, a site that offers easy-to-understand-and-follow advice on retirement and investing. Walter previously wrote the Ask the Expert column for and MONEY Magazine and has published four books on personal finance. If you have a question on retirement or investing that you would like Walter to answer online, send it to Ask Real Deal Retirement. You can follow Walter on Twitter @RealDealRetire and reach him at [email protected]. Read More
Next Avenue LogoMeeting the needs and unleashing the potential of older Americans through media
©2024 Next AvenuePrivacy PolicyTerms of Use
A nonprofit journalism website produced by:
TPT Logo