(An update on the following Next Avenue story, which appeared in March 2019)
On June 3, 2019, Sen. Bob Casey (D-Pa.) and Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Pa.) released a report called Families’ and Residents’ Right to Know: Uncovering Poor Care in America’s Nursing Homes. It included a list of nearly 400 nursing homes around the country where inspectors found serious ongoing health, safety or sanitary problems but whose names had not been publicly disclosed by the government. These nursing homes, with a “persistent record of poor care” do not appear on Medicare’s Nursing Home Compare site with a yellow triangle icon resembling a “caution” sign the way other homes, in the government’s Special Focus Facility program, do. The reason, according to the report by Senators Casey and Toomey:”a result of limited resources” at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
You probably saw the viral Facebook post by the Texas man who said he planned to move into a Holiday Inn rather than a nursing home because it would cost less. That’s a radical idea, and not an especially smart one. But with the average annual cost of a private room in a nursing home topping $100,000, according to Genworth, it pays to do diligent research to find a facility for your parent. And that means looking at nursing home ratings.
This type of detective work can be especially helpful if your mom or dad live in a rural part of the United States. As The New York Times reported this week, nursing homes in those places are increasingly shutting down. More than 400 rural nursing homes have closed or merged over the past decade, the Times said. That means families are being forced to expand their search for nursing homes just to find some.
What Is a Nursing Home?
Before I describe the Medicare and Yelp rating systems, a brief definition:
Nursing homes generally provide nursing care, meals, assistance with everyday activities and rehab services.
Assisted living facilities, by contrast, focus on helping residents with daily living activities and don’t offer as much medical care.
Medicare and Yelp Ratings of Nursing Homes
Both Medicare and Yelp rate nursing homes (sometimes called skilled nursing facilities) on a one-to-five-star scale. Medicare’s ratings of facilities it regulates are in the Nursing Home Compare part of the Medicare.gov site. The ones on Yelp show up if you do search for them with that online service.
But the two types of ratings are done very differently. So much so that Anna Rahman, an assistant professor at the USC Leonard Davis School of Gerontology who has studied them, recommends reading the Medicare reviews as well as the Yelp reviews to get a complete picture.
Rahman and her fellow researchers looked at 51 Yelp-rated nursing homes in California; they previously reviewed the Nursing Home Compare tool.
“We found the Yelp scores did not align well with the scores on Nursing Home Compare,” Rahman told me. “There are lots of possible reasons.”
Why the 2 Types of Nursing Home Ratings Are So Different
The biggest one: Medicare’s Nursing Home Compare star ratings measure facilities based on quantifiable data. Yelp’s reviews are more personal and qualitative. Rahman and her colleagues found that most Yelp reviews commented on “intangibles” like staff attitudes and responsiveness.
Put another way, Medicare can help show how well a nursing home is run and Yelp can show what nursing home residents, or their families, say it’s like to live there.
The Medicare Nursing Home Compare ratings are geographically comprehensive. When I looked for facilities near where I live in New Jersey, I received 160 ratings. (You can modify your search by number of miles, the name of a nursing home, star ratings and whether the facility accepts Medicare or Medicaid.)
By contrast, it’s harder to find many Yelp ratings for a particular area. And even if a nursing home is rated on Yelp, odds are there won’t be many reviews. When I did a Yelp search for nursing homes near me (I found 22), most had fewer than five consumer ratings. They rarely had more than eight.
How the Nursing Home Ratings Are Done
Nursing Home Compare gets its data from three sources: the federal government’s health inspection database; a national database of resident clinical data and Medicare claims data.
Medicare requires on-site inspections every 12 to 15 months. The nursing homes themselves typically report the staffing and quality measures. Critics believe some nursing homes game them.
To arrive at a star rating for a nursing home, Medicare starts with the health inspections rating, then adds a star for a good staffing rating or subtracts one for a one-star health inspections rating. Next, Medicare adds a star if the quality of resident care rating is five stars and subtracts one if that rating is just one star. And if the health inspections rating is just one star, the overall Nursing Home Compare rating can’t be upgraded by more than one star based on the staffing and quality of resident care ratings.
At Yelp, anyone can post a review based on any criteria he or she chooses to use.
When Rahman and her fellow researchers compared Medicare and Yelp nursing home ratings, they often found four or five stars on one but not the other. That’s not because one of the services is wrong; it’s that the raters rate different things.
An Expert’s Take on the Medicare and Yelp Ratings
Rahman is “frustrated” that Medicare has no consumer voice in its ratings system “even though we are supposedly moving to a patient-centric, family-directed health care system.”
Her advice when using its ratings: look for nursing homes that fare well in each of Medicare’s three broad measures: health inspections, quality of resident care and staffing.
“If I saw that a nursing home got five stars for quality measures, but two on staffing and two on health inspection, I’d move on,” she says. “I’d assume they were lying about quality. You can’t get great quality care when your staffing score sucks. You need staff to provide that care.”
Rahman also says the Yelp platform “has its own set of flaws,” although “they allow well-intended consumers to express an opinion about services they have been receiving.” But, she adds, family members often write these reviews. “And [loved ones who are] the residents, don’t necessarily agree. They often disagree.”
Merging Medicare’s Nursing Home Ratings With Yelp’s
She thinks “a nice solution” would be if Medicare and Yelp collaborated, because “people would like a Yelp-like score” on Nursing Home Compare.
“I don’t think it will happen,” says Rahman.
So for now, if not forever, check out nursing home ratings from Medicare and Yelp. Then be sure to visit facilities you’re considering to see for yourself. And don’t be shy about asking questions of administrators or staff (the Medicare Nursing Home Checklist can help).
With the steep cost of nursing homes, and often an urgency to locate a facility, you can’t afford to be.
Next Avenue Editors Also Recommend:
- What to Look For When Touring a Nursing Home
- The Nursing Home Rating System Gets a Reboot
- Yelp Adds Hospital and Nursing Home Reviews
Next Avenue brings you stories that are inspiring and change lives. We know that because we hear it from our readers every single day. One reader says,
"Every time I read a post, I feel like I'm able to take a single, clear lesson away from it, which is why I think it's so great."
Your generous donation will help us continue to bring you the information you care about. What story will you help make possible?